Children, the Latest Victims of COVID-19
That tiny consolation was shattered when very sick children began turning up in hospitals in Europe and the United States (Lancet 2020 May 13. [Epub ahead of print]). They took clinicians by surprise, admitted Michael Levin, MBE, PhD, FRCPCH, FMedSci, a professor of pediatrics and international child health at the Imperial College in London, England, where some of these cases were reported.
January was the start of COVID-19 in England, but it wasn’t until the end of March that “a number of pediatricians started noticing an unusual illness, and we had children who were admitted to pediatric intensive care units, critically ill with a very unusual syndrome,” Dr. Levin said.
The timing of their presentation was unusual, explained Stanford T. Shulman, MD, a professor of pediatrics in infectious diseases at Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine, in Chicago. “These patients are showing up in Northern Italy, London, Spain, France and now on the East Coast of the United States about a month or so after the peak of the COVID cases that are being seen in adults,” he said.
Many parents reported an exposure to COVID-19 about a month before the onset of symptoms, either a positive test in the child or a relative, added Cena Tejani, MD, the associate fellowship director of Pediatric Emergency Medicine at the Children’s Hospital of New Jersey at Newark Beth Israel Medical Center.
The first few cases were characterized as COVID-19-related Kawasaki disease (KD) because children presented with fever, sometimes a rash, conjunctivitis and cardiac signs, some of which are hallmarks of KD (Lancet 2020 May 13. [Epub ahead of print]).
First described in 1967, KD is a disease that tends to affect very young children—50% are younger than 24 months—and few children are older than 6 years of age. The etiology is unknown. KD diagnostic criteria require fever for five days, and then at least four other signs, including rash, conjunctivitis, changes in the tongue, lips or oral cavity, changes in the extremities and cervical lymphadenopathy. The most concerning cardiovascular effects of KD are coronary artery abnormalities that can lead to thrombosis, stenosis, aneurysms and myocardial infarctions (Pediatrics 2004;114:1708-1733. doi: 10.1542/peds.2004-2182).
But as more children presented with what is now called multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children (MIS-C), they came in with a more heterogeneous phenotype that was more like toxic shock and less like classic KD. “You probably have heard about these patients who have Kawasaki disease–like features temporally associated with COVID-19. We are also seeing patients with just myocarditis. We’re seeing patients with toxic shock, so it’s many different phenotypes. And it’s really hard to know exactly what is causing this,” said Lauren Henderson, MD, MMSc, an attending physician in the rheumatology program and an assistant professor of pediatrics at Boston Children’s Hospital.
“This appears to be a syndrome that is associated with COVID-19 and has a few similarities of Kawasaki disease but much more dramatic differences,” Dr. Shulman explained.
Kawasaki disease tends to affect young children; MIS-C is affecting children of all ages with a median of about 11 years old, according to Dr. Levin, who spoke during a CDC webinar (bit.ly/2Zc3bcn-IDSE). “Perhaps the most striking feature is that Kawasaki disease prior to COVID-19 was a disease of young children, and the comparison we did ... is that they tend to be older,” he said.
The rate of KD also is higher among Asian children, but this syndrome is not being seen in countries like China and Japan. “So, this is a very different demographic picture,” Dr. Shulman said.
The differences might be due to virus and host factors, according to Ashraf Harahsheh, MD, FACC, FAAP, an associate professor of pediatrics at the George Washington University School of Medicine and Health Sciences, in Washington, D.C. “Some believe that the virus underwent spontaneous mutation in Italy before coming to the East Coast and spreading through Europe. Maybe the mutation made the COVID-19 act like an epitope that triggers KD-like illness in the genetically susceptible child. This might explain why we have not seen it in China, Japan, etc.,” he said.
The clinical picture is also different. “With this new disease, patients may have one or two Kawasaki-type features like rash or some red eyes, but the dominant clinical features in the new syndrome are that patients have a lot of abdominal pain, diarrhea and some vomiting,” Dr. Shulman said.
Although MIS-C also affects the heart, it is not limited to the arterial signs seen in KD; children with MIS-C are developing a mild to severe myocarditis with shock and hypotension.
The laboratory features are also different, according to Dr. Shulman, an attending at the Ann & Robert H. Lurie Children’s Hospital of Chicago. The inflammatory marker C-reactive protein (CRP) is “a lot higher” in patients with MIS-C, he said. B-type natriuretic peptide (BNP), a marker of heart function, typically is normal or near normal in patients with KD, but is “extremely elevated in the new syndrome in children.” In addition, “white blood cell counts are substantially higher in the new syndrome and the lymphocyte counts are substantially lower,” Dr. Shulman said. Most patients have evidence of COVID, either by polymerase chain reaction or antibody test, he added.
“We shouldn’t be overly focused on whether or not COVID-19 triggers KD,” said Michael Bell, MD, the division chief of critical care medicine at Children’s National Hospital, in Washington, D.C. “It is clear that COVID-19 is triggering inflammation—the cytokine storm—in adults as well as children, on a scale that has not been seen with other respiratory viruses,” he said.
On May 14, the CDC issued an emergency health alert warning about MIS-C and its apparent relationship to COVID-19 and listing the diagnostic criteria for the syndrome (bit.ly/3bMfBw7-IDSE). The CDC alert describes pediatric patients with a persistent fever and a variety of signs and symptoms, including multiorgan involvement and elevated inflammatory markers.
Although the overall number of children presenting with MIS-C is still low, most of these kids are very sick; many require hospitalization; and although they are not experiencing the respiratory failure seen in adults, the children do require oxygenation. Some of these children also require ventilation or extracorporeal membrane oxygenation due to heart failure, and there have been deaths.
Dr. Tejani said children with the syndrome are coming through her ER, and she is seeing similar patients to those described by Dr. Shulman and others. “Kawasaki disease is something that we’ve all seen for a very long time, and it involves five days of fever and has to meet certain criteria. And the patients we’re seeing with this post-COVID infection are not really fitting these criteria firmly,” she said.
“All of these kids are presenting with fevers and tachycardia. Some of them have low blood pressure, and most of them seem very irritable. They are crying a lot,” Dr. Tejani said. Because her patients have been younger, it can be difficult to pinpoint the source of the pain, but she added that in some patients it appears to be abdominal pain.
“Most of them are febrile,” Dr. Henderson said. “A lot of them may have a rash. A lot of them seem to have GI symptoms, so a lot of abdominal pain, vomiting, diarrhea, and they come in very inflamed,” she said. “Often, they are having some type of end-organ damage.” Clinicians have seen heart involvement, GI involvement and cardiac shock. “These are the broad common brush strokes that we are seeing in these patients. But respiratory disease is not as prominent,” Dr. Henderson said.
“Features that seem more unique to MIS-C include the propensity for direct myocardial injury manifesting as higher troponin and BNP compared with the typical KD patient,” Dr. Harahsheh said, adding that some cases have significant anemia.
Some patients also manifest the more typical inflammation of coronary arteries seen in KD, he said.
The American Heart Association recommends a series of testing for these children, which includes sequential inflammatory markers, such as complete blood counts as well as differentials; CRP and erythrocyte sedimentation rate; coagulation studies such as D-dimer and ferritin; liver function tests; and a cytokine panel, according to Dr. Harahsheh. (The Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health offers diagnostic and monitoring information.)
“It’s a lot of tests that we’re sending, and I think part of the problem is that we’re not exactly sure what the syndrome is. In some cases, we’ve seen elevations in all of those,” Dr. Tejani said.
“We have recently developed a stepwise protocol that helps us decide which labs to send and which patients need to be admitted to the hospital. There is still ambiguity here, but we are beginning to collect data that we need to make decisions and clarify this post-inflammatory syndrome,” she added.
Perhaps because the initial presentation appeared to be KD, the treatments used in KD were the first ones tried in these patients. This includes aspirin, steroids and IV immune globulin (IVIG). Although it is becoming clearer that MIS-C is probably not KD, the fact that children are responding to KD medications makes intuitive sense on the basis of their anti-inflammatory properties, according to Jerry Siegel, PharmD, an expert in immune globulins. “IVIG has been recognized as an effective treatment to prevent coronary artery aneurisms in KD for many years,” Dr. Siegel said.
“While this new syndrome may be different from Kawasaki disease, there has been favorable response to high-dose (2-g/kg) IVIG, 30 to 50 mg/kg aspirin and steroids. The use of IVIG in these cases would be as an anti-inflammatory agent,” he said.
Some physicians are also giving interleukin inhibitors, and some institutions have had success with anakinra, an interleukin-1 receptor antagonist protein indicated for rheumatoid arthritis.
Most children testing positive for SARS-CoV-2 still have no or mild symptoms of disease, and do not have MIS-C, so some pediatricians and parents might be unsure when to refer because children with MIS-C should receive a multidisciplinary work-up.
“The public message in the UK was that patients should try and stay at home and not attend hospital because hospitals were under pressure,” Dr. Levin said. “And so children were remaining home with fevers for longer than they might have normally and arriving in a very seriously ill state. Now that we’ve become more familiar with this problem, there’s been a very clear public health message—if children have persistent fever, they do need to be evaluated,” he said.
Don’t Forget KD
Dr. Harahsheh said some of the children might actually have KD, which could be missed, so don’t totally discount it in your differential (J Pediatr 2020 May 6. [Epub ahead of print]). “Early in the COVID-19 pandemic, we KD experts were worried that more attention would be given to COVID-19 and cases of Kawasaki disease would be missed,” Dr. Harahsheh told Infectious Disease Special Edition. “We saw three cases, one at Children’s National, one at Boston and one in San Diego that presented late into their illness—more than 10 days from onset of fever. Our worry when we wrote this letter was missing KD in children,” he said.
A Final Consideration
Just about as quickly as the cases were reported, people started asking experts whether they finally discovered the etiology of KD. Both Drs. Shulman and Harahsheh, who have been researching KD for a long time, said that was unlikely.
“Kawasaki disease has been around at least for 60 years,” Dr. Shulman said. “This new virus has been around for a couple of months. Clearly, the new virus is not the cause of Kawasaki.”
Dr. Harahsheh agreed. “With more than 50 years since it was first described by Dr. [Tomisaku] Kawasaki, and more than 20 years of focused research, no single pathogen that triggers KD has been identified,” he said.
The sources reported no relevant financial relationships.
NOTE: After this article was published, the New England Journal of Medicine published several articles on this syndrome.